Grey's Anatomy and the gift or curse of accumulation
How billing decides a cast member's share.
In Part 3, Karl Urban took the biggest slice of the cast's credit on The Boys' first season, while Chace Crawford took almost none. That's not because the model watched the show and decided Urban drove ratings much more than Crawford. It's because Urban was billed first and Crawford eighth. This part explains how cast billing drives the cast portion of the model. I will also say out front that the cast portion really would benefit from better data to feed the model.
Billing
For each season, the model credits the top eight billed cast members. They don't share equally. The lead's share is the biggest, and each slot down the billing gets less, roughly 40% less than the slot above it. The idea is simple: the person whose name comes first is on screen the most and carries the most of the show, so they carry the most of its credit and its blame. The steepness of that drop wasn't picked by hand: we tested flatter and steeper curves and kept the one that best predicted future seasons, out of sample.
Twenty-three seasons of Grey's Anatomy
Credits are counted season by season, like wins above replacement in baseball: every season a show beats its baseline expectation, its people bank credit; every season it falls short, they lose some. Grey's Anatomy is the longest-running case we have. It opened at 7.70 in season 1, spent most of its first fifteen seasons above its baseline expectation, and has finished below it every season since 2019.
Now follow two people through it. Ellen Pompeo was billed first all 23 seasons. Chandra Wilson started at #6 and climbed the billing as the original cast left: #4 by season 7, and #2 from season 17 on. Every step up the billing gave her a bigger share of the show, and those steps came just as the show was sliding.
Pompeo's path looks very different. Her first ten seasons built a large positive record on the show. As described in Parts 2 and 3, her previous success on the show meant these later poor show ratings didn't completely torpedo her body of work.
Over the whole run, Pompeo finishes at +5.83 and Wilson at −2.61.
Ratings are IMDb user ratings from IMDb's public data files. Credits are from the model that built this page. Season 23 is the most recent.
Next in the series: Tying it all together (Part 5).