Jack Bender Just Passed 10 Career RAR as a Director
The Last of the 10 RAR Directors?
What do starting pitchers and TV directors have in common? The landscape of their work has changed drastically over the last 10 years.
For the longest time, the ultimate crowning achievement of a starter's career, the single most impressive mountain to summit, was the 300-win club. There are 24 members. But the club has been adding members at a vastly decreasing rate. Here is a timeline of the day each pitcher joined. Only five have joined since 1990, and the most recent was Randy Johnson in 2009.
Several factors are behind that. The most salient is diminished pitch counts to protect the health of starting pitchers, which shares some commonalities with load management in basketball. Another is more aggressive use of the bullpen to blunt the so-called "third time through the order" effect, which posits that starters become less effective each successive time a hitter sees them in a game, from a combination of familiarity and fatigue. Finally, players are debuting at older ages, given the popularity of attending college and the longer time spent developing in the minor leagues. Add it all up, and some believe we may never see another 300-win pitcher.
There are some pretty obvious comparisons to television here. With the dawn of streaming, the average number of episodes per season and the average number of seasons per series are both down. People a lot smarter than me can speculate why. I assume the incentive structure has changed, from dollars generated per episode aired to dollars generated through adding and keeping users on a streaming platform. Whatever the reason, it's fair to assume that writers and directors will no longer log the sheer volume of episodes of their pre-2000 counterparts.
Which makes it extremely noteworthy that legendary director Jack Bender surpassed 10 RAR this year. Where does that place him on the all-time directors' list? Stick around for a brief summary of Jack's amazing career, and to find out.
The career
When I hear the name Jack Bender, my mind goes straight to Lost. But his career started well before then. He got his start on the 1979 CBS drama The Paper Chase, which follows law student James T. Hart and his classmates at an unnamed law school. He directed episode 22, "Scavenger Hunt," in which the law students... were given a scavenger hunt to complete. He worked steadily for the next two decades, on plenty of familiar shows (all of them are in the chart further down). He even directed 4 episodes of The Sopranos, including "The Weight," where Johnny Sack catches Ginny eating candy in the basement.
His first extended run of success came on Alias (shoutout Rambaldi). Among many impressive achievements, he directed what the model considers Alias's best episode, "Phase One," which earned him +0.44 RAR.
His magnum opus, though, is his work on Lost: +5.15 RAR over 39 episodes. Surprisingly, his work directing "The Constant," widely considered one of the best episodes of television ever, is only the second-best performance of his career according to our model (+0.48). The model gives him slightly more credit for From's Season 3 episode "There and Back Again" (+0.52). For all you Fromheads out there, this is the episode where Tabitha returns with Victor's father.
To sum it up: Bender has spent 47 years directing television. 93% of his value came in the second half of that span, and he's still posting elite performance in volume: 8 episodes in 2026 (6 of them From), worth +0.90 RAR.
The all-time top 10
With that all said, where does he stack up? Scroll for No. 10 through No. 1.
No. 10
Noam Pitlik · +7.47 over 206 episodes, 1975–1991
+6.06 RAR from an absurd 102 episodes of Barney Miller, but also an absurd +2.59 RAR over just 11 episodes of Taxi, including the standout "Jim's Inheritance."
No. 9
Greg Beeman · +7.56 over 133 episodes, 1992–2023
Smallville's director: +4.56 RAR from just 19 episodes, including "Reckoning" (+0.68). Then Falling Skies, Nash Bridges, and Lucifer.
No. 8
Terrence O'Hara · +8.44 over 233 episodes, 1992–2022
Generated more than 1 RAR across 4 different series: NCIS: Los Angeles, Renegade, NCIS, and Grimm.
No. 7
Harry Harris · +8.61 over 350 episodes, 1960–2007
Legendary long-time director of The Waltons and In the Heat of the Night. Unfortunately, he gave some back at the end of his career: −0.58 RAR over 34 episodes of 7th Heaven.
No. 6
Lee Philips · +8.67 over 97 episodes, 1965–1995
Mr. Efficiency. An absurd +8.67 RAR over just 97 episodes, almost all of which were The Andy Griffith Show (+8.28 over 59).
No. 5
Jack Bender · +10.10 over 172 episodes, 1979–2026
Our guy. 0.31 behind Christopher Chulack, which is about 3 more episodes at his From rate.
No. 4
Christopher Chulack · +10.41 over 134 episodes, 1995–2026
44 episodes of ER, as well as great runs on Southland, SEAL Team, and Third Watch.
No. 3
Joel Zwick · +10.79 over 353 episodes, 1978–2016
97 episodes of Full House, including his biggest Full House overperformance, "Happy Birthday, Babies: Part 2" (+0.64). He also logged serious time on Perfect Strangers, Hangin' with Mr. Cooper, Bosom Buddies, and Step by Step.
No. 2
Andy Cadiff · +13.07 over 417 episodes, 1989–2021
Prolific sitcom volume shooter. 417 episodes over 29 series. Most RAR generated by Hot in Cleveland, Spin City, The Exes, Home Improvement, and My Wife and Kids.
No. 1
Martin Wood · +16.31 over 178 episodes, 1997–2026
The GOAT. An absurd +16.31 RAR over just 178 episodes, an average of +0.09 per. Over +11.40 from Stargate SG-1 and Stargate: Atlantis alone.