| 1 | Oct 5, 2003 | Girl Who Signed Wolf | 7.7early |
| 92 |
7.24 | +0.50 | Joan Considine Johnson +0.08, Nickolas Barris +0.09 | David Warry-Smith +0.09 |
| 2 | Oct 12, 2003 | The Sniper | 7.8early |
| 80 |
7.10 | +0.74 | Dave Alan Johnson +0.03, Steve Moore +0.04, Gary R. Johnson +0.02 | Holly Dale +0.08 |
| 3 | Nov 2, 2003 | Homeland Security | 7.6early |
| 79 |
7.07 | +0.57 | Dave Alan Johnson +0.03, Joan Considine Johnson +0.04, Nickolas Barris +0.05, Gary R. Johnson +0.03 | Larry A. McLean +0.05 |
| 4 | Nov 9, 2003 | Cold Case | 7.2early |
| 82 |
7.13 | +0.11 | Lance Kinsey −0.10, Gary R. Johnson −0.14 | David Warry-Smith −0.07 |
| 5 | Nov 16, 2003 | The Newlywed Game: Part 1 | 8.2early |
| 89 |
7.06 | +1.18 | Dave Alan Johnson +0.22, Gary R. Johnson +0.21 | Larry A. McLean +0.20 |
| 6 | Nov 23, 2003 | Breaking Up Is Hard to Do: Part 2 | 7.5early |
| 72 |
7.06 | +0.48 | Dave Alan Johnson −0.05, Gary R. Johnson −0.05 | J. Miles Dale −0.03 |
| 7 | Jan 11, 2004 | Bad Hair Day | 7.9early |
| 96 |
6.32 | +1.62 | Joan Considine Johnson +0.15, Nickolas Barris +0.15 | Bruce Pittman +0.16 |
| 8 | Jan 18, 2004 | Political Agenda | 7.4early |
| 70 |
6.34 | +1.10 | Brad Markowitz −0.11 | Alan Goluboff −0.09 |
| 9 | Feb 8, 2004 | The Gambler | 7.4early |
| 71 |
6.44 | +1.00 | Dave Alan Johnson −0.06, Gary R. Johnson −0.06 | Larry A. McLean −0.05 |
| 10 | Feb 15, 2004 | Into Thin Air | 7.6early |
| 68 |
6.44 | +1.20 | Brad Markowitz −0.02, Ken Hanes −0.02, Kim Beyer-Johnson +0.01 | David Warry-Smith −0.00 |
| 11 | Feb 22, 2004 | To Grandmother's House We Go | 7.7early |
| 65 |
6.47 | +1.27 | Joan Considine Johnson +0.05, Kim Beyer-Johnson +0.09 | Holly Dale +0.06 |
| 12 | Apr 4, 2004 | The Lawyer | 7.5early |
| 73 |
6.42 | +1.12 | Dave Alan Johnson +0.01, Nickolas Barris +0.04 | Larry A. McLean +0.00 |
| 13 | Apr 11, 2004 | The Holocaust Survivor | 7.8early |
| 78 |
6.34 | +1.50 | Joan Considine Johnson +0.23 | Dave Alan Johnson +0.09 |
| 14 | Apr 18, 2004 | The Mentor | 7.7early |
| 69 |
6.34 | +1.40 | Dave Alan Johnson +0.06, Nickolas Barris +0.11 | Larry A. McLean +0.06 |
| 15 | Apr 25, 2004 | Rocket Man | 7.4early |
| 75 |
6.34 | +1.10 | Brad Markowitz −0.09, Kim Beyer-Johnson −0.04 | Holly Dale −0.06 |
| 16 | May 2, 2004 | Elvis Is in the Building | 7.6early |
| 74 |
6.34 | +1.30 | James Keenley +0.04, Joan Considine Johnson +0.04, Gary R. Johnson +0.02 | Bruce Pittman +0.08 |
| 17 | May 9, 2004 | Hit and Run | 7.6early |
| 75 |
6.34 | +1.30 | Joan Considine Johnson +0.01, Kim Beyer-Johnson +0.04 | David Warry-Smith +0.02 |
| 18 | May 16, 2004 | Concrete Evidence | 7.6early |
| 69 |
6.46 | +1.18 | Steve Moore −0.04 | J. Miles Dale −0.02 |
| 19 | May 23, 2004 | The Kiss | 7.5early |
| 99 |
6.60 | +0.94 | Dave Alan Johnson −0.09, Brad Markowitz −0.06, Ken Hanes −0.07 | Larry A. McLean −0.12 |