| 1 | Sep 23, 1958 | Gold Fever | 7.4early |
| 33 |
Terry Ryan −0.18, Neil Simon −0.14 | Aaron Ruben −0.13 |
| 2 | Oct 1, 1958 | Bilko's Vampire | 8.2early |
| 37 |
Arnie Rosen +0.09, Coleman Jacoby +0.09 | Aaron Ruben +0.08 |
| 3 | Oct 8, 1958 | Bilko's Deluxe Tours | 8.1early |
| 34 |
Arnie Rosen +0.05, Coleman Jacoby +0.05 | Aaron Ruben +0.05 |
| 4 | Oct 15, 1958 | Bilko the Potato Sack King | 7.9early |
| 36 |
Terry Ryan −0.05, Neil Simon −0.02 | Aaron Ruben −0.03 |
| 5 | Oct 22, 1958 | Bilko vs. Covington | 8.3early |
| 34 |
Terry Ryan +0.05, Arnie Rosen +0.05, Neil Simon +0.07 | Aaron Ruben +0.07 |
| 6 | Oct 28, 1958 | Bilko Joins the Navy | 8.7early |
| 46 |
Terry Ryan +0.30, Neil Simon +0.36 | – |
| 7 | Nov 5, 1958 | Bilko's Big Woman Hunt | 8.3early |
| 34 |
Terry Ryan +0.07, Neil Simon +0.11 | Aaron Ruben +0.07 |
| 8 | Nov 12, 1958 | The Bilkos and the Crosbys | 7.4early |
| 25 |
Terry Ryan −0.21, Neil Simon −0.18 | – |
| 9 | Nov 19, 1958 | Bilko's Allergy | 8.1early |
| 30 |
Arnie Rosen +0.05, Coleman Jacoby +0.05 | Aaron Ruben +0.04 |
| 10 | Nov 26, 1958 | Bilko and the Chaplain | 8.3early |
| 32 |
Arnie Rosen +0.10, Coleman Jacoby +0.10 | Aaron Ruben +0.09 |
| 11 | Dec 3, 1958 | Bilko Presents the McGuire Sisters | 7.6early |
| 30 |
Terry Ryan −0.16, Phil Sharp −0.16 | – |
| 12 | Dec 10, 1958 | Bilko's Secret Mission | 7.9early |
| 34 |
Arnie Rosen −0.01, Coleman Jacoby −0.01 | Aaron Ruben +0.00 |
| 13 | Dec 17, 1958 | Bilko's Giveaway | 8.3early |
| 31 |
Arnie Rosen +0.10, Coleman Jacoby +0.10 | Aaron Ruben +0.09 |
| 14 | Dec 22, 1958 | Bilko and the Medium | 8.1early |
| 32 |
Terry Ryan +0.01, Neil Simon +0.04 | Aaron Ruben +0.02 |
| 15 | Jan 1, 1959 | Bilko's Bopster | 8.0early |
| 32 |
Arnie Rosen +0.02, Coleman Jacoby +0.02 | Aaron Ruben +0.03 |
| 16 | Jan 9, 1959 | Bilko's Hollywood Romance | 7.9early |
| 33 |
Arnie Rosen −0.01, Coleman Jacoby −0.01 | Aaron Ruben +0.00 |
| 17 | Jan 28, 1959 | Keep in Step | too few votes |
| 18 |
– | – |
| 18 | Feb 4, 1959 | Bilko's Grand Hotel | 8.0early |
| 35 |
Terry Ryan −0.02, Neil Simon +0.01 | Aaron Ruben +0.00 |
| 19 | Feb 11, 1959 | Bilko's Credit Card | 7.6early |
| 29 |
Arnie Rosen −0.08, Coleman Jacoby −0.08 | Aaron Ruben −0.06 |
| 20 | Feb 18, 1959 | Viva Bilko | 7.5early |
| 35 |
Terry Ryan −0.18, Neil Simon −0.13 | Aaron Ruben −0.12 |
| 21 | Feb 25, 1959 | The Colonel's Promotion | 8.6early |
| 34 |
Arnie Rosen +0.28, Coleman Jacoby +0.28 | – |
| 22 | Mar 4, 1959 | Bilko's Sharpshooter | 7.8early |
| 31 |
Terry Ryan −0.11, Neil Simon −0.07 | – |
| 23 | Mar 18, 1959 | Bilko's Formula Seven | 8.3early |
| 32 |
Arnie Rosen +0.10, Coleman Jacoby +0.10 | Aaron Ruben +0.10 |
| 24 | Mar 25, 1959 | Bilko's Ape Man | 8.3early |
| 34 |
Arnie Rosen +0.11, Coleman Jacoby +0.11 | Aaron Ruben +0.10 |
| 25 | Apr 3, 1959 | Warrant Officer Papparelli | 8.0early |
| 31 |
Terry Ryan −0.02, Neil Simon +0.01 | Aaron Ruben +0.00 |
| 26 | Apr 17, 1959 | Bilko's Godson | 7.6early |
| 32 |
Terry Ryan −0.14, Neil Simon −0.09 | Aaron Ruben −0.09 |
| 27 | Apr 24, 1959 | Guinea Pig Bilko | 7.9early |
| 31 |
Arnie Rosen −0.01, Coleman Jacoby −0.01 | Aaron Ruben +0.00 |
| 28 | May 1, 1959 | Bilko the Butler | 7.9early |
| 28 |
Arnie Rosen −0.01, Coleman Jacoby −0.01 | Aaron Ruben +0.00 |
| 29 | May 8, 1959 | Ritzik Goes Civilian | 8.2early |
| 32 |
Arnie Rosen +0.07, Coleman Jacoby +0.07 | Aaron Ruben +0.07 |
| 30 | May 15, 1959 | Bilko's Small Car | 8.4early |
| 32 |
Terry Ryan +0.09, Neil Simon +0.13 | Aaron Ruben +0.09 |
| 31 | May 20, 1959 | Doberman Missing Heir | 8.0early |
| 30 |
Arnie Rosen +0.02, Coleman Jacoby +0.02 | Aaron Ruben +0.03 |
| 32 | May 29, 1959 | Bilko's Casino | 8.1early |
| 30 |
Terry Ryan +0.01, Neil Simon +0.04 | Aaron Ruben +0.02 |
| 33 | Jun 5, 1959 | The Colonel's Second Honeymoon | 8.3early |
| 32 |
Arnie Rosen +0.10, Coleman Jacoby +0.10 | Aaron Ruben +0.10 |
| 34 | Jun 12, 1959 | Bilko in Outer Space | 8.1early |
| 36 |
Terry Ryan +0.01, Neil Simon +0.05 | Aaron Ruben +0.03 |
| 35 | Jun 17, 1959 | The Bilko Boycott | 7.9early |
| 34 |
Arnie Rosen −0.04, Coleman Jacoby −0.04 | Aaron Ruben −0.02 |