| 1 | Sep 30, 1959 | The Stagecoach Story | 7.2early |
| 118 |
Jean Holloway −0.10 | William Witney −0.06 |
| 2 | Oct 7, 1959 | The Greenhorn Story | 7.6early |
| 137 |
Jean Holloway +0.14 | Bretaigne Windust +0.04 |
| 3 | Oct 14, 1959 | The C.L. Harding Story | 6.9early |
| 119 |
Howard Christie −0.18, Jean Holloway −0.20 | Herschel Daugherty −0.16 |
| 4 | Oct 21, 1959 | The Estaban Zamora Story | 7.1early |
| 111 |
Halsey Melone −0.25 | Bretaigne Windust −0.12 |
| 5 | Oct 28, 1959 | The Elizabeth McQueeny Story | 7.9 |
| 345 |
Allen H. Miner +0.30 | Allen H. Miner +0.10 |
| 6 | Nov 4, 1959 | The Martha Barham Story | 6.9early |
| 109 |
Katherine Albert −0.11, Howard Christie −0.10, Dale Eunson −0.11, James A. Parker −0.10 | James Neilson −0.18 |
| 7 | Nov 11, 1959 | The Cappy Darrin Story | 6.5early |
| 98 |
Stanley Kallis −0.66 | Virgil W. Vogel −0.27 |
| 8 | Nov 18, 1959 | The Felizia Kingdom Story | 8.0early |
| 119 |
Leonard Praskins +0.21, Sloan Nibley +0.19 | Joseph Pevney +0.15 |
| 9 | Nov 25, 1959 | The Jess MacAbee Story | 7.7early |
| 152 |
Howard Christie +0.07, James A. Parker +0.07, Jean Holloway +0.06 | David Butler +0.07 |
| 10 | Dec 2, 1959 | The Danny Benedict Story | 7.2early |
| 117 |
Harold Swanton −0.17 | Herschel Daugherty −0.09 |
| 11 | Dec 16, 1959 | The Vittorio Bottecelli Story | 7.4early |
| 105 |
Howard Christie +0.01, Jean Holloway −0.01 | Jerry Hopper −0.00 |
| 12 | Dec 23, 1959 | The St. Nicholas Story | 7.7early |
| 122 |
Jean Holloway +0.21 | Bretaigne Windust +0.07 |
| 13 | Dec 30, 1959 | The Ruth Marshall Story | 7.6early |
| 108 |
Joseph Stone +0.05, Jean Holloway +0.04, Paul King +0.05 | Richard Bartlett +0.05 |
| 14 | Jan 6, 1960 | The Lita Foladaire Story | 6.9early |
| 105 |
Helen Cooper −0.16, Jean Holloway −0.16 | Jerry Hopper −0.14 |
| 15 | Jan 13, 1960 | The Colonel Harris Story | 7.5early |
| 111 |
Gene L. Coon +0.03, Virgil W. Vogel +0.02 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.03 |
| 16 | Jan 20, 1960 | The Maidie Brant Story | 6.8early |
| 111 |
Oliver Crawford −0.22, Milton Krims −0.23 | Virgil W. Vogel −0.17 |
| 17 | Jan 27, 1960 | The Larry Hanify Story | 7.3early |
| 115 |
Harold Swanton −0.12 | Ted Post −0.05 |
| 18 | Feb 10, 1960 | The Clayton Tucker Story | 7.1early |
| 119 |
Jeffrey Shorling −0.11, Thomas Thompson −0.12 | Virgil W. Vogel −0.09 |
| 19 | Feb 17, 1960 | The Benjamin Burns Story | 8.2early |
| 115 |
Gene L. Coon +0.28, Virgil W. Vogel +0.27 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.23 |
| 20 | Feb 24, 1960 | The Ricky and Laurie Bell Story | 6.5early |
| 108 |
Allen H. Miner −0.70 | Allen H. Miner −0.29 |
| 21 | Mar 2, 1960 | The Tom Tuckett Story | 8.3early |
| 132 |
Jean Holloway +0.62 | Herschel Daugherty +0.27 |
| 22 | Mar 9, 1960 | The Tracy Sadler Story | 7.9early |
| 111 |
Eric Norden +0.15, Norman Jolley +0.17 | Ted Post +0.12 |
| 23 | Mar 16, 1960 | The Alexander Portlass Story | 7.5early |
| 125 |
Peter Barry +0.02, Leonard Praskins +0.02, Dick Nelson +0.01 | Jerry Hopper +0.01 |
| 24 | Mar 23, 1960 | The Christine Elliott Story | 8.0early |
| 124 |
Jean Holloway +0.41 | Herschel Daugherty +0.18 |
| 25 | Mar 30, 1960 | The Joshua Gilliam Story | 7.7early |
| 102 |
Gene L. Coon +0.20 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.08 |
| 26 | Apr 6, 1960 | The Maggie Hamilton Story | 7.0early |
| 138 |
Allen H. Miner −0.34 | Allen H. Miner −0.14 |
| 27 | Apr 13, 1960 | The Jonas Murdock Story | 7.7early |
| 99 |
Norman Jolley +0.20 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.08 |
| 28 | Apr 20, 1960 | The Amos Gibbon Story | 7.5early |
| 100 |
Gene L. Coon +0.07 | Joseph Pevney +0.02 |
| 29 | Apr 27, 1960 | Trial for Murder: Part 1 | 7.9early |
| 106 |
Jean Holloway +0.37 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.16 |
| 30 | May 4, 1960 | Trial for Murder: Part 2 | 8.0early |
| 104 |
Jean Holloway +0.44 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.19 |
| 31 | May 11, 1960 | The Countess Baranof Story | 7.1early |
| 103 |
Lee Karson −0.13, Norman Jolley −0.12 | Ted Post −0.11 |
| 32 | May 18, 1960 | The Dick Jarvis Story | 8.0early |
| 111 |
Floyd Burton +0.42 | Jerry Hopper +0.16 |
| 33 | May 25, 1960 | Dr. Swift Cloud | 7.8early |
| 98 |
Floyd Burton +0.28 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.12 |
| 34 | Jun 1, 1960 | The Luke Grant Story | 7.4early |
| 114 |
Donald Gorman −0.03 | Christian Nyby −0.03 |
| 35 | Jun 8, 1960 | The Charlene Brenton Story | 8.1early |
| 115 |
Floyd Burton +0.49 | Virgil W. Vogel +0.21 |
| 36 | Jun 15, 1960 | The Sam Livingston Story | 7.6early |
| 101 |
Harold Swanton +0.02 | Joseph Pevney +0.00 |
| 37 | Jun 22, 1960 | The Shadrack Bennington Story | 7.9early |
| 107 |
Fred Cassidy +0.14 | Jerry Hopper +0.04 |