Ratings through the latest IMDb dataFollow @screenballtv@screenballtvscreenballtv@gmail.com
ScreenBall
‹ Back
Series · ABC · 1991–1995

TheCommish

5Seasons
92Rated episodes
7.21Avg rating
+4.40RAR added
ProceduralEnded 199592 cases on file

Tony Scali is a former Brooklyn cop now the Police Commissioner of a small upstate city. But for Scali, this is no desk job. He's a tough yet compassionate boss, a loving husband and father, and a hands-on law enforcer with an unorthodox style of bending the rules. From parenthood to politics, from sex crimes to murder cases, one man takes it day-to-day with offbeat humor and street- smart skill.

Where to watchUS streaming · via JustWatchIMDb ↗

Seasons

Open a season for its people and episodes
Full season table
SeasonYearEpsRatingForecastvs forecastShowrunnerBilled #1Season's top creditSeason RAR
Season 1199122 7.12 6.90+0.22 Stephen J. CannellMichael Chiklis Robert Cochran +0.40+0.98
Season 2199222 7.30 6.59+0.73 Stephen J. CannellMichael Chiklis Robert Rabinowitz +0.33+1.33
Season 3199322 7.18 6.95+0.23 –Michael Chiklis Joel Surnow +0.33+1.06
Season 4199422 7.27 6.74+0.54 –Michael Chiklis Joel Surnow +1.20+0.98
Season 519954 7.04 7.28−0.27 –Michael Chiklis Jon Boorstin +0.55+0.06
The Commish · rate leaders

Percentile rankings

What each person did per turn on this show, graded against everyone who held the same job on any series.

Min seasons 2Min episodes 3 Sort
Percentile vs. same job, all seriesPoorAvgGreatRate
1Joel SurnowWR 88 +0.13/ep12 episodes2David EhrmanWR 87 +0.12/ep4 episodes3Anthony J. SchembriWR 85 +0.11/ep4 episodes4Robert RabinowitzWR 85 +0.11/ep4 episodes5Evan KatzWR 85 +0.11/ep3 episodes6Christina CovinoWR 82 +0.10/ep4 episodes7Barbara AmatoDIR 80 +0.06/ep4 episodes8Les SheldonDIR 76 +0.05/ep3 episodes9Robert CochranWR 61 +0.04/ep19 episodes10Bruce KesslerDIR 57 +0.02/ep5 episodes11Rachel FeldmanDIR 54 +0.02/ep4 episodes12Stephen J. CannellWR 53 +0.02/ep3 episodes13Glen MorganWR 48 +0.01/ep8 episodes14James WongWR 48 +0.01/ep8 episodes15Tammy AderWR 47 +0.01/ep5 episodes
Rate = RAR per season worked (showrunners), RAR per unit of billing opportunity (cast: total RAR ÷ the weight their billing slots carry, 1.82 for #1 down to 0.06 for #8), or per episode written or directed (writers, directors). Seasons after someone left are excluded. Percentile compares that rate with everyone in the same job on every series; cast are compared only with people at the same billing (their opportunity-weighted average slot, rounded) (2+ seasons or 3+ episodes); rates in different units are only compared through their percentiles.

The people

Everyone credited on the show, by unit, sorted by the RAR they added. Each person's RAR is their share plus their replacement piece, so the units add up to the show's total.

Showrunners

1 person · +0.00 total
#NameSeasonsRAR ▼Per seasonBest
1Stephen J. Cannell 2 +0.00 +0.00S1

Cast

13 people · +0.37 total
#NameBilledSeasonsRAR ▼Per seasonBest
1Michael Chiklis 15 +0.15 +0.03S4
2Theresa Saldana 25 +0.09 +0.02S4
3Kaj-Erik Eriksen 35 +0.05 +0.01S4
4Darren McGavin 61 +0.04 +0.04S5
5Gina Belafonte 42 +0.03 +0.02S2
6Melinda McGraw 43 +0.02 +0.01S2
7Jason Schombing 42 +0.02 +0.01S4
8Nicholas Lea 52 −0.00 −0.00S2
9Dave Cameron 81 −0.00 −0.00S5
10John Novak 71 −0.01 −0.01S5

Writers

26 people · +4.78 total
#NameEpsRAR ▼Per epBest
1Joel Surnow 12 +1.53 +0.13S4E18
2Robert Cochran 19 +0.72 +0.04S1E19
3Jon Boorstin 2 +0.55 +0.28S5E3
4David Ehrman 4 +0.49 +0.12S5E4
5Anthony J. Schembri 4 +0.45 +0.11S1E15
6Robert Rabinowitz 4 +0.44 +0.11S2E9
7Christina Covino 4 +0.38 +0.10S1E20
8Evan Katz 3 +0.32 +0.11S3E16
9Toni Perling 1 +0.26 +0.26S4E5
10Marilyn Osborn 1 +0.15 +0.15S2E14

Directors

32 people · −0.74 total
#NameEpsRAR ▼Per epBest
1Barbara Amato 4 +0.23 +0.06S4E6
2David Nutter 2 +0.19 +0.09S2E5
3Les Sheldon 3 +0.15 +0.05S1E20
4Paul Shapiro 2 +0.11 +0.06S3E4
5Bruce Kessler 5 +0.10 +0.02S3E16
6James Head 2 +0.10 +0.05S4E5
7James A. Contner 2 +0.10 +0.05S4E20
8Sara Rose 2 +0.09 +0.04S3E5
9Brad Turner 1 +0.08 +0.08S1E19
10Michael Zinberg 2 +0.08 +0.04S2E2

Page style: Deconstructed with the procedural layer, after how deconstructed 90s magazine type presented shows (ABC, 1991). See every style.